11 Underscored editors share the jewelry pieces they wear on repeat

I’ve bought multiple pieces of jewelry from Mejuri (call me obsessed), including these trendy Charlotte Bold Hoops. I've been into silver jewelry lately and purchased these chunky silver ones, which I’ve been wearing nonstop. Even though hoops are about as basic as you can get, I feel like this pair elevates all my outfits and I can’t get over how cute they look in my ear. — Rachel Dennis, editorial coordinator 

I’m obsessed with this ring and get showered with compliments every time I wear it. I love the subtle bling and find that I can wear it with both silver and gold jewelry thanks to the layer of micro pavé crystal. It gives the illusion of stacked rings without the inconvenience of them (I always find stacked rings quite uncomfortable). I have the cuff to match that I only wear on really special occasions, and I have my eye on a pair of earrings from the Solanales collection. I love most of Alexis Bittar’s stuff and usually treat myself to a piece on my birthday or drop strong hints to loved ones around the holidays. — Rachel Quigley, managing editor 

These modular earrings are super cool. They come with two post options and two ear jacket options, so you can customize your look. I’ve always been a bit envious of people with a full ear stack, and as someone with only single piercings on each lobe, I feel like these allow me to get creative with it in a similar way. My favorite combo of the moment is the gem earring with the circle hoop ear jacket. — Sophie Shaw, beauty and fashion editor 

When I first decided to commit to being a gold jewelry girlie, I placed an order at Bohomoon, mainly because even though I loved the look of necklaces, I didn’t want to drop a fortune on something I wasn’t 100% sure I would get a lot of wear out of. I’m happy to report that I still wear my Bohomoon jewelry often and love their heavy, chunky feel. Many of the styles I have are no longer in stock, but this simple T-bar necklace is one of my favorites to wear when I feel like my neck needs a little extra something. After three years, my necklaces are still in great shape and though the brand claims its jewelry is tarnish-free and waterproof, I tend to still take it off before I sweat or shower. — Jillian Tracy, associate editor 

If you know me, I like to stack two things: my rings and my earrings. I added this classic piece to my ring party last Black Friday since it was on sale (Mejuri rarely has sales). It perfectly complements my other three stackable diamond rings — I wear this every single day and never take it off since it’s 14-karat gold. You can’t beat the price for the quality, either. I recommend checking out Mejuri’s other finds — I also recently snagged these perfect everyday huggies. — Tamara Kraus, senior lifestyle editor  

From an engagement shoot and a casual backyard hang to a winery wedding and the Fourth of July, these versatile silver statement hoops have complemented every outfit I’ve worn this summer — no matter the occasion. They’re also under $100, waterproof, tarnish-resistant and best of all, practically weightless. — Stephanie Griffin, social lead 

Catbird is one of my favorite jewelry brands — if you’ve seen me in person, you know I have stacks of their zapped “forever bracelets” on both wrists (which unfortunately you can only get at a physical store location). Aside from those, I still love (and own) way too many Catbird pieces for my own good, including my current favorite: this simple but stunning gold chain. Better than your average chain, it’s exceptionally shiny and subtly unique. I rarely take it off and am usually seen wearing it with a few of Catbird’s dainty charms. — Chelsea Stone, editorial director 

If you know me, you know I’ve long been a fan of Kendra Scott since I worked in the store in college. What you might not know is that while the brand is largely known for its Color Bar and bright gemstones, the Austin, Texas-based retailer also has an affordable high-end jewelry line, too. I have so many pieces, but this edgy, yet classic ring is one of my favorites. I love already having jewelry on when I wake up, so I feel more polished. — Tamara Kraus, senior lifestyle editor 

When it comes to jewelry, I’m all about two things: never having to take pieces off and never having to replace them due to tarnishing, and these earrings fit the bill perfectly. At the time, I was just looking for something easy to wear that would prevent my piercing holes from closing and my expectations for a $9 pair of earrings from Amazon were low, but after over four years of everyday wear, these earrings still look as good as the day I bought them. I liked them so much I even bought a smaller second pair to fill my additional piercing hole. Comfortable, lightweight, secure and above all, tarnish-resistant, the only time these hoops leave my ears is when I need to clean them. — Jillian Tracy, associate editor

I’m pretty lazy with my jewelry — I usually keep the same necklace, bracelet and earrings (all handed down from family) — on for weeks at a time. The only pieces I regularly swap out are rings, wearing a few scattered across my fingers, and this is one of my favorites. I’m all for the mixed metal look, and I find having a couple pieces that feature gold and silver together make it easier to mix and match other pieces I’m wearing too. I love the modern look of this ring and how it goes with nearly all my other jewelry. — Sophie Shaw, beauty and fashion editor 

This was a gift from a very dear friend who knows I wear my Scorpio badge with pride. The sterling silver pendant has a sprinkling of white sapphire stars made from precious and semi-precious stones. I haven’t taken it off since I received it last November and it still looks brand new. Sometimes I’ll layer it with another necklace, but I think I love it just as much on its own. These make a great birthday gift for an astrology-loving friend. — Rachel Quigley, managing editor 

I love a layered necklace look, but you wouldn't believe the amount of time I spend re-clipping my necklaces in the morning so they sit just right. These necklace extenders have given me much more versatility with my jewelry, letting me adjust my necklaces to the perfect length so they don’t look overcrowded or tangled. — Jillian Tracy, associate editor 

When I want to mix up my ring assortment with something a bit more feminine, I add in this sparkly set. It’s a great price for three rings that you can stack together or wear separately. I may have twisted my partner’s arm into buying it for me while we were holiday shopping last year, and I’m so glad I did. — Sophie Shaw, beauty and fashion editor  

Simple, elegant and so light I forget I'm even wearing it, this Armenian Initial Bracelet from IceLink is part of the stack I keep on my wrist every day. I wear a lot of bracelets, and while the rotation has changed over the years, my Armenian Initial Bracelet grounds the collection I sport. This 14-karat gold-plated piece features white gemstones encrusted in my initial and is a timeless staple that’s stood the test of time. — Gareen Puglia, associate testing writer 

I love Swarovski and can rarely, if ever, walk by a store without at least looking at the window display or going in to see all the shiny, twinkly items on display. I got this ring as a Christmas present a few years back, and though this color is no longer available, I found the white rhodium and zirconia version on Swarovski’s site that I may have to add to my wish list this year! I love the pop of color on mine but the overall spiral design of this ring is what I love most about it, so I think this version is just as cute. — Rachel Quigley, managing editor 

If you’re looking to snag some rainbow bracelets for the Eras Tour (or want to keep the party going post-concert), I’ve been obsessed with Little Words Project. You can customize one or buy an already-made bracelet that’s adorned with encouraging and fun phrases. I got one with my initials in gold letters, my birthstone charm and zodiac charm. I'm already eyeing the next bracelets to add to my wrist. — Tamara Kraus, senior lifestyle editor 

Both I and the jewelry industry are going through a freshwater pearl phase right now. I spotted this necklace and bracelet set in the San Francisco MoMA gift shop and was immediately charmed by how delicate yet funky the pieces were. — Rena Behar, copy editor 

I love the look of hands dripping with rings (à la Harry Styles), but I always run into a few issues. The rings get dirty, snag my hair or clothes and chunky rings just look a bit too overpowering. That’s why I was stoked to find Simple & Dainty. I never take these rings off — from the office to the pool to the shower, they hold up and don’t get in my way. After more than two years of 24/7 wear, I think they still look pretty good. I built my own ring stack to get exactly the look I was after and I love that the simple, classic design goes with everything. — Jillian Tracy, associate editor 

I’ve never been one to wear much jewelry. I probably haven’t worn anything since donning a $10 puka shell necklace at age 12. But this year, I wanted to switch it up and possibly venture into Ring Guy territory. I wanted something simple but not boring. This braided rope ring was the perfect find. It's simple and elegant, but the ring is interesting enough to start a conversation. It was a bit more expensive than I would have liked but the sterling silver means I don’t have to worry about my fingers changing colors. — Daniel Rathburn, programming editor

Like many other editors, I’m a big fan of Mejuri’s ring offerings. My go-to for a hint of sparkle is this slim signet ring. It’s subtle enough for everyday wear, and it looks great stacked with a few of my other Mejuri and Catbird favorites. — Chelsea Stone, editorial director 

This past spring, I decided that while I love my chunkier necklaces, I wanted something more minimal and suited for all-day, everyday wear. So, during a sale, I ordered a few necklaces from D. Louise including the Very Fine Essentials Necklace and the Can’t Decide Necklace. It wasn’t a brand I had come across before, but I loved the simple designs, brand story and that they offer a lifetime guarantee against any color fading. For around $150, I treated myself to a simple stack of three necklaces that have since become my go-to during hot, sweaty summer days. — Jillian Tracy, associate editor 

Trends come and go, but timeless pieces like a striking necklace will never go out of style. This piece from Pico Jewelry is bound to dazzle during every big moment in life. Made from 14-karat gold and set with real diamonds and an emerald-cut ruby, this elegant necklace will add a touch of glamour to any outfit. — Carolina Gazal, associate testing writer

I’ve always dreamed of having an epic ring stack, so almost immediately after I got engaged, I began scouring the internet for a wedding band. I eventually landed on this timeless 6mm curve band that’s made from recycled gold, and you can engrave something special on the inside for free. I can’t wait until the day I can wear it! — Stephanie Griffin, social lead

The vast majority of my jewelry has been purchased either from tents or while on the road (often both). This necklace was one of my first nicer craft fair purchases (thank you Renegade Craft) and has had a solid place in my necklace rotation for many years now. It’s sleek and just a little bit edgy, and has a satisfying weight to it that keeps it nicely in place. — Rena Behar, copy editor